This post was originally published on September 14, 2020 and gets updated periodically to remove outdated links and grow this list with new items! I’ll be reviewing this post, adding new products, and cleaning up any broken links that don’t work anymore; with its most recent update being its current publishing date. Follow me on Facebook to keep informed on when this and other Roundup Posts get updated!
This post contains affiliate links, meaning that if you click on a link I will recieve a small comission. This costs you nothing extra and I only promote products I use and love! You can read our full disclosure here
Baby Showers are always a fun celebration to buy gifts for; there’s nothing better than helping your best friends and family prepare for the first or newest little one in their life. While there are so many fun and unique options for baby gifts out there, I wanted to make a list of affordable choices that are one of a kind gifts that any new mother will love. In that spirit, I have created a collection of beautiful baby shower gift options from my favorite online storefront for handmade items, Etsy, with all these super cute presents available for under $25!
1. Personalized Kids Name Blanket
For the perfect going home blanket, why not these fleecy personalized name blankets? These blankets come in a rainbow of color choices and can be personalized with the baby's name and a heart if desired, with the small blankets being the perfect size for a baby blanket!
When I was a little one, my absolute favorite toy was my teddy bear, in fact I still have it today as a keepsake. So when I saw these adorable teddy bears with personalized shirts, I had to include them! These bears come in either white or brown with the tshirt being personalized to the newest arrival’s name and birthday, and for a little over $25 you can include it in a customizable gift box for easy giving.
3. Crocheted Carrot Baby Rattle
For an adorable rattle and teether that grows up for pretend play, this crocheted carrot baby rattle is the perfect pick! These eco-friendly rattles are made of 100% cotton, stuffed with organic natural wool as well as being 100% handmade for a truly special baby gift!
4. Crocheted Woodland Animal Baby Rattles
To go with that adorable carrot rattle, I had to include these crocheted woodland critter rattles too! These rattles come in a variety of animals to choose from, and while keeping them plain keeps them in budget, for only a few cents over you can get them engraved with the new baby’s name!
5. Cassette Tape Silicone Teethers
For a fun retro teether that music lovers will adore, look no further than these adorable cassette tape teethers! These toxin free silicone teethers come in a half dozen fun colors and the best part? They are dishwasher safe too!
If you have explored my Baby Shower Bento Boxes, you know I absolutely adore cleverly folded baby gifts to present to new mamas, so when I saw these adorable receiving blankets folded into cute cupcakes, I had to share them! These cupcakes come in three color options; pink blue and yellow, and can be decorated with an artificial cherry or binkie charm on top.
7. Flamingo Fabric Pacifier Clips
For a set of festive fabric pacifier clips that are sure to impress, these flamingo and pink clips are my favorite! Each of these cute clips comes in under $10 a piece, or you can get the whole set of four for a little over $25.
8. Hand Stamped Metal Baby Spoons
For a beautiful personalized gift perfect for feeding time, these hand stamped metal baby spoons are a unique and useful gift! These spoons come as a set of two, either purple and pink or teal and blue, with the option of being personalized with the first or first and middle name of the expected tot.
9. Monogrammed Critter Lovie Blanket
If there’s one thing I always hear that mother’s love, it has to be the soft minky lovies that their children cuddle! These monogrammed blankets come embroidered with a personalized monogram and are available in a variety of animals depending on the nursery theme, mother’s choice, or your own favorite!
10. Name Embroidered Fox Luvster Blanket
For a foxy embroidered cuddle buddy, this one is my favorite! This cuddly and adorable blanket is embroidered with the full name of the baby in one of dozens of different thread colors, but I love the burnt orange with this fuzzy fox.
Whether it's for taking baby pictures with or as a beloved stuffed animal keepsake for your baby, these Personalized Elephants are a unique and memorable gift for any new mother. Each elephant is customized with your little one’s initial and name on one ear, with their birth date, time, weight and length on the other ear, with the initial available in a variety of colors.
12. Floral Fleece Wooden Baby Teether
I had to include this minky teether too because I just love the fabrics used in this shop, And being right around the price of the other teethers, you have even more pretty options that aren’t too pricey! These teethers only come in a minky backing, but this floral fleece teether will still be sure to be beloved.
13. Personalized Girl Mama Mug
For a great gift for a girl mama on all those early mornings, this personalized mug is a wonderful choice! This modern mug comes in two sizes and is printed with the baby’s name and birthday, a first mother’s day gift she’s sure to love!
14. New Mother Personalized Key Chain
For a personalized keepsake that new parents can see every time they go for a drive, look no further than these personalized key chains! These hand stamped key chains are personalized with the baby’s name, birth weight, length, birth date and time, along with the option to add their birthstone for a little extra sparkle!
15. Personalized Wooden Stacking Ring Toy
My favorite toy growing up was stackable ring sets, so when I saw this adorable animal themed set I knew I had to include it! These rings come personalized with the baby’s name and in one of three animal options, an adorable piece of nursery decor and then a great toddler toy later!
16. Inkless Handprint and Footprint Kit
For a memorable keepsake for any new parents, these inkless hand print and foot print sets are the perfect for safely and easily getting pictures of little fingers and toes! Each set comes with two A5 sheets of inkless paper along with all the instructions and supplies needed for the project, all wrapped in a pretty gift box!
For a girly and romantic mama mug, look no further than this beauty! Each mug can be printed on either or both sides in a variety of fonts and colors, perfect to personalize for any mother to be.
Sometimes, coffee just isn't enough to get a new mom through her day, and these wine labels are perfect for giving the gift of grapes to any great mum who needs a break! This set of hilarious and true labels are perfect for adorning and gifting your new mom’s favorite wines, along with some humor that is always needed during the first months of babyhood!
19. Family of Three Christmas Tree Ornament
For a memorable gift that they can admire every future holiday season, this personalized ornament is an adorable gift option. The name under each tree can be personalized along with the year of baby’s first Christmas.
20. Personalized Macrame Baby Pacifier Clip
For a beautifully boho baby gift that is useful too, these macrame pacifier clips are a perfect pick! With eight different macrame options in over a dozen colors, these clips are then laser engraved with the name of the baby receiving it in a variety of fonts.
21. Personalized Wooden Name Blocks
These wooden blocks are the perfect toy box addition for any tot or as adorable décor in their nursery! Made of your choice of maple or walnut, each block after the first is a little under $5 so you can purchase several while staying in budget, with each block personalized to the letters you want.
For a funny and unique baby rattle for a superhero fan, look no further than these Thor themed baby rattles! Each rattle comes in a choice of three handle colors with the choice of he or she for the hammer inscription, so it's perfect for either boys or girls.
23. Personalized Engraved Baby Spoon
For an adorable and affordable baby feeding gift, these personalized engraved spoons are the perfect choice! The handle is personalized with the baby’s name in over a dozen fonts with several spoon colors to choose from.
24. Rainbow Themed Baby Clothing Dividers
For an adorable and useful nursery gift these clothing dividers are wonderful for organizing a little one’s new clothes in the closet! Each set comes with dividers from newborn through 24 months with cute little rainbows on each, perfect for any nursery!
25. Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Nursery Sign
Finally, I had to finish this baby shower gift list with the cutest little wall decor sign for a new nursery! Handcrafted with the words of one of my favorite baby songs, this plaque is the perfect accessory for any nursery and is sure to be beloved by any new parents.
RECENT BLOG POSTS:
OUR PINS FOR THIS POST:
